Skip to content

Flexible Pavement Empirical Design Example

Reviewed by licensed engineers

Checked against its sources by licensed professional engineers on the previous site, where reviewers weren’t recorded by name.

How articles are reviewed

On this page · 7 sections
  1. Solution
  2. ESALs per year
  3. Design ESALs
  4. Calculate the Effective Subgrade Support
  5. Calculator: 1993 AASHTO flexible pavement design
  6. Calculator: Design ESALs with traffic growth
  7. Use the 1993 AASHTO Empirical Equation

Design a new flexible pavement for a major interstate highway using the following conditions (four lanes each direction):

Table 1.
Pavement location:Urban
Pavement functional classification:Interstate
Number of lanes:3 lanes in each direction
Traffic distribution:Assume 80% of the loading occurs in the design lane
Annual growth rate:Assume 2%
Design period:Investigate 20, 30 and 40 year design periods
Construction Materials:Surface course: 12.5 mm (0.5 inch) Superpave with E = 3,447 MPa (500,000 psi)Binder course: Dense-graded HMA mix with a nominal maximum aggregate sizeof 25 mm (1 inch). Use E = 3,447 MPa (500,000 psi)Base course: Crushed aggregate with M_R= 193 MPa (28,000 psi)Subbase course: None used
Subgrade:M_R = 103 MPa (15,000 psi) in the dry months of May through October M_R = 86 MPa (12,500 psi) in the wet months of November through April
Overall serviceability loss:p_o – p_t = 4.5 – 3.0 = 1.5
Reliability:Investigate three levels: R = 90%, R = 95%, R = 99%. This represents a typical range of reliability levels encountered for Interstate highways.
S_o:0.50
Traffic count:Single unit trucks (assume 0.40 ESALs per truck) = 1872/day
Double unit trucks (assume 1.00 ESALs per truck) = 1762/dayDouble unit trucks (assume 1.00 ESALs per truck) = 1762/day
Truck trains – trucks with more than 2 units (assume 1.75 ESALs per truck) = 247/dayTruck trains – trucks with more than 2 units (assume 1.75 ESALs per truck) = 247/day

Solution

By looking at several different design periods and reliability levels this example gives an idea of the relative influence of these inputs. Work can be verified by using the Flexible Pavement Structural Design Utility.

ESALs per year

This step involves converting the daily traffic volume into an annual ESAL amount. Pavements are typically designed for the critical lane or "design lane", which accounts for traffic distribution.

ESALs per year = (Vehicles/day) (Lane Distribution Factor) (days/yr) (ESALs/Vehicle)

Table 2.
Singles:(1872/day) (0.8) (365) (0.40)equals218,650 ESALs/yr
Doubles:(1762/day) (0.8) (365) (1.00)equals514,504 ESALs/yr
Trains:(247/day) (0.8) (365) (1.75)equals126,217 ESALs/yr
Totalequals859,371 ESALs/yr
Rounded totalequals860,000 ESALs/yr

Design ESALs

The standard multiplier to calculate compound growth is:

multiplier=(1+g)n−1g\text{multiplier} = \frac{(1+g)^n-1}{g}
Table 3.
20 year design life:860,000[(1+0.02)20−10.02]≅21,000,000860{,}000\left[\dfrac{(1+0.02)^{20}-1}{0.02}\right]\cong 21{,}000{,}000
30 year design life:860,000[(1+0.02)30−10.02]≅35,000,000860{,}000\left[\dfrac{(1+0.02)^{30}-1}{0.02}\right]\cong 35{,}000{,}000
40 year design life:860,000[(1+0.02)40−10.02]≅52,000,000860{,}000\left[\dfrac{(1+0.02)^{40}-1}{0.02}\right]\cong 52{,}000{,}000

Calculate the Effective Subgrade Support

Note that in this example there are two different values of subgrade resilient modulus given: one for dry months and one for wet months. Realistically, subgrade support varies even more than this simplistic assumption, however, the same method for estimating a design subgrade resilient modulus can be used for more precise assumptions. The standard method in the 1993 AASHTO Guide for Design of Pavement Structures involves calculating a weighted average subgrade resilient modulus based on the relative pavement damage. Because lower values of subgrade resilient modulus result in more pavement damage, lower values of subgrade resilient modulus are weighted more heavily. The relative damage equation used in the 1993 AASHTO Guide for Design of Pavement Structures is:

uf=(1.18×108)MR−2.32u_f = \left(1.18\times 10^{8}\right)M_R^{-2.32}
Table 4.
where:u_fequalsrelative damage factor
M_Requalsresilient modulus in psi

Therefore, over an entire year the calculations would be:

Table 5.
MonthM_Ru_f
January86 MPa (12,500 psi)0.037
February86 MPa (12,500 psi)0.037
March86 MPa (12,500 psi)0.037
April86 MPa (12,500 psi)0.037
May103 MPa (15,000 psi)0.024
June103 MPa (15,000 psi)0.024
July103 MPa (15,000 psi)0.024
August103 MPa (15,000 psi)0.024
September103 MPa (15,000 psi)0.024
October103 MPa (15,000 psi)0.037
November86 MPa (12,500 psi)0.037
December86 MPa (12,500 psi)0.037
Table 6.
average relative damageequalsu‾f=(6×0.037)+(6×0.024)12=0.0305\overline{u}_f = \dfrac{(6\times 0.037)+(6\times 0.024)}{12} = 0.0305
Table 7.
Rearrange the relative damage equation and getMReff=3005(0.0305)−0.431=13,500 psi=93 MPaM_{R_{\mathit{eff}}} = 3005(0.0305)^{-0.431} = 13{,}500\ \mathrm{psi} = 93\ \mathrm{MPa}
Calculator

1993 AASHTO flexible pavement design

1993 AASHTO Guide, Part II §3.1

Finds the structural number the traffic needs, then the layer depths that provide it, layer by layer from the top.

Units
Traffic and reliability

Total 18-kip (80 kN) ESALs in the design lane over the design period.

Typically 0.40 to 0.50 for flexible pavements.

Serviceability
Structure
HMA surface
Base
Subbase
Example values. Layer coefficients and drainage coefficients come from your agency’s design manual.
Calculator

Design ESALs with traffic growth

1993 AASHTO Guide, Appendix D
Daily traffic, both directions or design direction
Distribution and growth

50 % if the counts are for both directions; 100 % if they are for the design direction.

Example values from the flexible pavement design example. Use load equivalency factors for your pavement type and region.

Use the 1993 AASHTO Empirical Equation

Using the previously calculated ESAL results and the 1993 flexible pavement structural design equiation the following pavement thickness designs can be calculated:

Table 8.
Design PeriodDesign Period ESALsPavement LayerLayer Thickness
Reliability = 90%Reliability = 95%Reliability = 99%
20 years<21,000,000HMA Surface Course105 mm (4.2 inches)105 mm (4.2 inches)105 mm (4.2 inches)
HMA Binder Course130 mm (5.1 inches)150 mm (5.8 inches)180 mm (7.21 inches)
Base Course135 mm (5.4 inches)135 mm (5.4 inches)135 mm (5.4 inches)
SN4.795.105.70
<30 years<35,000,000HMA Surface Course105 mm (4.2 inches)105 mm (4.2 inches)105 mm (4.2 inches)
HMA Binder Course150 mm (6.0 inches)170 mm (6.7 inches)205 mm (8.1 inches)
Base Course135 mm (5.4 inches)135 mm (5.4 inches)135 mm (5.4 inches)
SN5.175.496.11
<40 years<52,000,000HMA Surface Course105 mm (4.2 inches)105 mm (4.2 inches)105 mm (4.2 inches)
HMA Binder Course170 mm (6.6 inches)190 mm (7.4 inches)225 mm (8.8 inches)
Base Course135 mm (5.4 inches)135 mm (5.4 inches)135 mm (5.4 inches)
SN5.475.806.44
Layer coefficients used were 0.44 for HMA and 0.13 for crushed stone
Frost design requirements must be checked if subgrade soil frost susceptible

In this particular example, which only shows one set of possible solutions, the HMA surface course and base course layer depths were kept constant and the HMA binder course depth was varied depending upon requirements. Notice also that a change in reliability level from 90% to 99% results in a SN increase of about 1.0 and a resultant increase in HMA thickness of about 55 mm (2 inches). It is interesting to note that in most empirical design procedures HMA, no matter what the specific mix designation or size, is treated equally. Here, the 12.5 mm (0.5 inch) Superpave surface course and the 25 mm (1 inch) dense-graded binder course are structurally equivalent.

Teaching this? Figures and worked examples are free to use with credit. How to cite

Cite this page

APA

Pavement Interactive. (2018, August 2). Flexible pavement empirical design example. HeadLight. Retrieved [the date you read it], from https://pavementinteractive.org/reference-desk/design/structural-design/flexible-pavement-empirical-design-example/

ASCE

Pavement Interactive. (2018). “Flexible Pavement Empirical Design Example.” HeadLight, <https://pavementinteractive.org/reference-desk/design/structural-design/flexible-pavement-empirical-design-example/> ([the date you read it]).

BibTeX

@misc{pavint-flexible-pavement-empirical-design-example,
  author = {{Pavement Interactive}},
  title = {Flexible Pavement Empirical Design Example},
  year = {2018},
  publisher = {HeadLight},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pavementinteractive.org/reference-desk/design/structural-design/flexible-pavement-empirical-design-example/}},
  note = {Accessed [date]}
}
This address will not change. The citation records the date you read it.
Report an error

Reports go to the editors, who check them against the cited sources. Corrections are noted at the top of the article.

Only if you want a reply. It is not published.